A murder, an FBI manhunt and a secret life of ‘Runaway Joe’
One of the oldest unsolved cases in the FBI’s files has deep roots in Ireland... and a local writer may hold the key to helping solve it.
Pavel Barter answered a phone call from a Dublin police station at his home in Warrenpoint last week to hear that the FBI wants to speak to him about a man who has eluded them for six decades.


That man’s name is Joseph Maloney - known to some as Michael O’Shea - and in his debut book, ‘Runaway Joe’- based on his podcast of the same name - Pavel tells the story of Maloney and follows his trail after he allegedly escaped justice for a second time.
While working on an edition of The Sunday Times Ireland Culture section, Pavel, a journalist of over 25 years, came across a review of a memoir by a retired court judge in Dublin.


“Within the review, it mentioned briefly a very unusual case that she had overseen in 1985, which was the attempted extradition of a man from America. He was wanted by the FBI on the charge of killing his wife in Upstate New York in 1967 and had been living in Ireland for almost 20 years under another identity,” explained the Rostrevor native.
Having already established himself as a prolific documentarian, through a number of award-winning podcasts - including ‘Grief of a Nation’, the story of an Irish photographer who captured the events surrounding JFK's assassination, which won Gold at the New York Festivals in 2021 - this titbit was more than enough to pique Pavel’s interest and steer him into a tangled web that would span continents and lead to unforeseen outcomes.
“What I discovered was there were still people around who were involved in the story, including a man called Neal Dunkelberg, who Joe Maloney had allegedly acquired a bottle of methyl alcohol from in 1967.”
Maloney allegedly poisoned his wife, June, at their son's fifth birthday party with two cocktails which had methyl alcohol, commonly known as antifreeze, in them.


“I phoned Neal Dunkelberg. We had a conversation. And that was how the journey began for me.”
The podcast ‘Runaway Joe’, made for the RTÉ Radio 1 Documentary on One series, won the IMRO Radio Awards Podcast of the Year award in 2024 and won European Best Investigative Documentary award at the Prix Europa Awards in Berlin.
On the back of that success, Pavel began working on his book ‘Runaway Joe’. In it, he delves deeper into the story and reveals more information discovered since the podcast ended.
“The unusual part of the podcast series is that it was a live investigation. We had the basis of the story that began around 55 years beforehand. But we were also investigating the story as to where Joe Maloney is now.
"So, at the end of each episode, we put out an appeal requesting information from listeners. And we were bombarded with calls by people who knew Joe Maloney in Ireland.”
Maloney arrived in Ireland with nothing, but he quickly rose to the top of the social strata.
“He owned a garage in Dun Laoghaire, so many people in the South Dublin area would have known him. He also bought a vast country estate in County Laois, so he was known very much by people in the aristocracy and by politicians. According to some stories, he even knew Charlie Haughey. He also worked in the movie industry with people like Pierce Brosnan.
“Underneath all of it was a very manipulative, very clever, very shrewd man.”
A revelation Pavel discovered in writing the book came from the son of Joe Maloney - “Joey, my friend” - who received a dossier from his father’s lawyer from when Maloney lived in America. The lawyer had since died, so attorney client privilege didn't apply anymore. Within this dossier was the result of the psychiatric assessment that was done on Maloney during his time in the psychiatric hospital before he escaped.
“That laid out quite clearly what his diagnosis was. I reveal it in the book.”
One positive, unforeseen consequence that came from this tragic story was the friendship that developed between Pavel and Joey.
When Maloney allegedly killed his wife, they had two children, Joey and Patty Ann. It was Joey's fifth birthday when it was claimed he fed his wife the poison cocktails. The two children were effectively orphaned and were swept up into the adoption system and never heard from again... until Pavel received an email.
“During the making of the podcast we were doing an interview with a local branch of National Public Radio (NPR) in Rochester, Upstate New York, which is where the story happened. Someone heard this and our appeal for the children of Joe Maloney to come forward. They forwarded that message to Joey, who now lives in Florida.”
Seemingly a bit reticent to reveal his surname, Joey contacted Pavel with a fake email address.
“He said, ‘Hi, Pavel. I am Joey, the man you're looking for, the son of Joe Maloney.’
“And I thought, ‘yeah, right’, but it turned out he was. And now Joey's one of my best friends.”
And that’s just one strand in a chain of happy events that came from investigative journalism at its finest.
While Pavel’s book and podcast track Joe Maloney, the most important person in the story for him has always been June.
“For me, June is the impetus really behind the book. As interesting and as fascinating a character as Joe Maloney is, I find June a much more fascinating character, because she had to put up with this person and she left him, which at the time must have been very difficult. One of the main contributors to my book was June's best friend, Wanda.”
He discovered that June was training to be a nurse in Genesee Hospital in Rochester.
"He basically swept her off his feet with all his plans and how he was going to be a millionaire.” When Joe’s plans inevitably failed, and after June had abandoned her training, she gave her new baby to her best friend to look after for six months while she went back to college and finished her training. Eventually she became a head nurse at the local hospital.
“She was really a remarkable person. She was only 26 when she died.”
‘Runaway Joe’ has been optioned for a TV series and Pavel has been busy at work on a new radio documentary and for the past 10 years on his feature film, which is a Cold War story about another unsolved mystery.
‘Runaway Joe’ is available in bookshops, including Elk Books, The Bookshelf, Waterstones and on Amazon from April 2